What the Russell Brand trial teaches us about survivors, trauma and workplace investigations

The questioning of survivors during the Russell Brand trial has reignited debate about rape myths and the assumptions we make about sexual violence. Those same assumptions can have serious consequences for how allegations are investigated in the workplace.

Words by William Richards | Founder, EthicsVision International | Former BBC Head of Whistleblowing

The conviction and sentencing of Russell Brand for rape and sexual assault has prompted considerable discussion about the behaviour of powerful individuals, the institutions that enable misconduct, and the difficulties faced by those who come forward to report sexual violence.

However, another important debate has emerged concerning the conduct of the trial itself, particularly the way in which complainants were questioned by Brand’s defence barrister and the continued influence of deeply embedded myths about sexual violence.

It is a debate that deserves attention, and one which I believe has significant implications beyond the criminal justice system, particularly for those responsible for conducting workplace investigations and disciplinary hearings.

The questioning of survivors at the heart of the Russell Brand trial debate

During Russell Brand's trial, his defence barrister, Ian Winter KC, questioned complainants about their behaviour during and following the alleged assaults, including why they had not physically resisted, attempted to leave or reported the incidents sooner.

In his closing remarks, Winter told the jury that "not one of them resisted or screamed or even tried to leave". He also drew attention to the delays in reporting the allegations, questioning why the women had not complained sooner.

These arguments attracted considerable criticism, including from the End Violence Against Women Coalition (EVAW), which warned that the defence had relied on harmful and outdated assumptions about how survivors of sexual violence are expected to behave.

The concern is that questioning of this nature can encourage juries to judge someone's credibility against their own expectations of how a person experiencing sexual violence should respond. A complainant who did not fight back, attempt to escape or immediately report an assault may be viewed with suspicion, despite there being no single or predictable response to such experiences.

There are, of course, important principles to balance here. Defendants are entitled to a fair trial, and defence barristers have a professional responsibility to challenge evidence, test accounts and advance their clients' cases, however distasteful or objectionable the arguments they are instructed to advance may be. But there is a difference between properly examining the evidence and inviting a jury to draw adverse conclusions from behaviour that may be entirely consistent with an experience of sexual violence.

The issue has attracted increasing regulatory and parliamentary attention. In May 2026, the Bar Standards Board established an expert reference group to help develop specialist professional standards for barristers working on rape and serious sexual offence cases, with a particular emphasis on trauma-informed advocacy.

Following Brand's trial, there have also been renewed calls for judges to be required to give juries specific directions about rape myths and stereotypes, rather than leaving such directions to judicial discretion.

These developments are important, but the wider issue is one of understanding. Assumptions about how someone should react to sexual violence can influence how their evidence is received and assessed, even when those assumptions have little basis in the reality of people's experiences.

There is no 'normal' response to sexual violence

Central to this debate is the recognition that there is no single or predictable way in which someone will respond to sexual violence. Most people are familiar with the ‘fight or flight’ response to threatening situations. However, our understanding of responses to fear and trauma extends beyond these two possibilities.

The concept of ‘freeze’ recognises that an individual may become temporarily unable to react, speak or move when experiencing an overwhelming threat. Rather than attempting to escape or resist, their response may be one of involuntary immobility. There is also increasing recognition of what is sometimes described as the ‘fawn’ response, where someone attempts to reduce a perceived threat by appeasing, accommodating or placating the person responsible.

Rape Crisis England & Wales describes five common responses to danger: fight, flight, freeze, flop and friend. The latter includes attempts to negotiate with or placate someone who presents a threat.

These responses help explain why a person experiencing sexual violence may not resist, may appear compliant, or may behave in ways that seem inconsistent with what others expect. Importantly, behaviour after an incident can also be difficult to interpret. Someone may continue communicating with the person responsible, exchange apparently friendly messages, or attempt to resume normal interactions.

Indeed, the Crown Prosecution Service’s own guidance explicitly recognises that people may maintain contact with an alleged perpetrator, including through friendly messages, for reasons connected to their safety or an attempt to regain a sense of normality.

None of these behaviours automatically establishes what happened. They do, however, demonstrate the danger of treating an individual’s response as inherently credible or incredible simply because it conforms to, or departs from, our expectations.

We ask the same questions in workplace investigations

While the current debate has focused on criminal proceedings, the assumptions being challenged are by no means confined to courtrooms. They exist throughout society and can have a significant influence on the way allegations of sexual misconduct are handled within organisations.

Consider, for example, an employee who reports that a senior colleague has repeatedly made unwanted sexual comments or behaved inappropriately towards them. During the investigation, it emerges that the employee laughed at some of the comments, continued to work productively alongside the colleague, exchanged friendly messages with them and waited several months before raising a formal complaint.

For an investigator or disciplinary hearing manager who approaches the evidence with preconceived ideas about how someone experiencing harassment should behave, these circumstances might immediately raise doubts about the allegation.

Why did they laugh if they found it offensive? Why continue working with the individual? Why send friendly messages? And if the conduct was genuinely unwanted, why wait so long to report it?

These may be legitimate matters to explore during an investigation. However, the conclusions drawn from the answers require considerable care. An employee may laugh at an inappropriate comment because they feel uncomfortable, wish to avoid confrontation or are concerned about damaging an important working relationship.

They may continue working with someone because their role requires it, because the individual holds influence over their career, or because they do not believe raising a concern will achieve anything positive.

Friendly messages may reflect an attempt to maintain a functional professional relationship rather than genuine approval of the behaviour being complained about.

And delays in reporting may arise from embarrassment, uncertainty, fear of repercussions, concerns about not being believed or simply needing time to recognise and process what has happened.

None of these explanations should automatically be accepted as proof of misconduct. Equally, the behaviour itself should not be treated as evidence that misconduct did not occur. The responsibility of an investigator is to explore these circumstances fairly, consider the available evidence in its full context and avoid allowing personal assumptions to substitute for objective analysis.

Being a senior manager doesn't make someone a competent hearing manager

There is another important dimension to this issue. Even where a workplace investigation has been conducted thoroughly and sensitively, the ultimate assessment of misconduct may rest with a disciplinary hearing manager who has little or no specialist understanding of sexual harassment, trauma or the complexities of workplace power dynamics.

That individual may be responsible for determining whether an allegation is substantiated and what disciplinary action, if any, should follow. A hearing manager might attach considerable weight to the fact that a complainant continued socialising with the person accused, did not object immediately to an inappropriate joke or appeared perfectly comfortable in subsequent workplace interactions.

Without sufficient understanding of the reasons people may respond in these ways, there is a risk that personal perceptions of what constitutes ‘normal’ behaviour become influential in determining the outcome. In some cases, those assumptions may be entirely unconscious.

This is particularly concerning where organisations provide training for investigators but assume that senior managers are sufficiently experienced to conduct disciplinary hearings without equivalent preparation.

The ability to manage people, lead a department or make difficult business decisions does not necessarily equip someone to assess allegations of sexual misconduct fairly.

It requires an understanding of the relevant standards of behaviour, the evidential questions being considered and the potential influence of power, fear, trauma and organisational culture. It also requires a willingness to examine one’s own assumptions.

Understanding trauma doesn't mean assuming guilt

There is an important distinction between understanding the possible effects of trauma and approaching an investigation with a presumption that an allegation must be true. Workplace investigations must remain impartial. Those accused of misconduct have the right to have allegations tested properly, to provide their own account and to have potentially contradictory evidence considered.

An understanding of trauma should inform how evidence is gathered and evaluated. It should never become an explanation automatically applied to every inconsistency or a reason to disregard evidence that challenges an allegation.

Equally, investigators and hearing managers must recognise that their own experiences, beliefs and expectations are not necessarily reliable indicators of how another person should have behaved. This is reflected in Acas guidance on handling sexual harassment complaints, which specifically warns employers against allowing personal views to influence their handling of allegations.

The same guidance recognises that complaints raised long after an incident must still be taken seriously and investigated as far as reasonably possible.

These principles should be reflected in the training, investigation procedures and decision-making frameworks used by organisations.

What needs to change in workplace investigations

The developments following Russell Brand’s trial have created an important opportunity to examine the influence of harmful assumptions within the criminal justice system. But I would argue that we should be having the same conversation about workplace investigations and disciplinary proceedings.

If professional standards for barristers are being strengthened to reflect a better understanding of sexual violence and trauma, there is a compelling case for ensuring that workplace investigators and hearing managers receive similarly informed guidance and training.

This has particular relevance at a time when employers in Great Britain are subject to strengthened legal responsibilities to take all reasonable steps to prevent workplace sexual harassment. Effective prevention depends, in part, on employees having confidence that concerns will be taken seriously and assessed fairly.

Where investigations or disciplinary decisions are influenced by stereotypes about how someone experiencing harassment should behave, organisations risk reaching flawed conclusions, discouraging others from speaking up and allowing harmful workplace cultures to persist.

The debate surrounding Brand’s trial should therefore extend beyond the courtroom. Because the same assumptions that can undermine confidence in criminal proceedings can also influence the decisions being made every day within HR departments, workplace investigations and disciplinary hearings.

And challenging those assumptions is an essential part of ensuring that allegations of sexual misconduct are investigated fairly, responsibly and with the rigour they deserve.

How EthicsVision can help

At EthicsVision International, we support organisations in handling sensitive allegations of misconduct through independent investigations, specialist training and advice. Our courses include Safeguarding and SEAH Investigations, with a focus on survivor-centred and trauma-informed practice, alongside Investigative Interviewing, Workplace Investigations and Investigation Report Writing.

Through our MastVision Collective partnership with Mast People Support, we also deliver dedicated Hearing Manager Workshops, helping those responsible for disciplinary decisions assess evidence impartially, challenge their own assumptions and reach fair, well-reasoned outcomes.

Our training can be tailored to the needs of individual organisations, with programmes delivered in person or online.

Next
Next

Russell Brand, David Walliams and the television industry's continuing problem with speaking up